Union Kitchen | Resources — Union Kitchen

Best Practices for Selecting Ingredients That Scale

Written by Barney Rubin | Oct 9, 2025 7:12:07 PM

A product changes long before it reaches a shelf. Sometimes, it starts with a small decision—where an ingredient comes from or what form it takes. When Samy, founder of Snacklins, began scaling production, he learned this quickly. The yuca that puffed perfectly in one test batch turned soggy in the next. Each supplier’s yuca absorbed water differently, shifting the texture, shelf life, and flavor.

Those small differences in ingredients become large differences in results. As you build toward consistent production, your ingredient list becomes a blueprint—one that balances stability, cost, and supply.

Ingredient Stability

Every ingredient behaves according to its chemistry. Heat, time, and mechanical stress expose that behavior. When batches get bigger, even familiar ingredients can act differently.

Starch, for example, can replace bread crumbs as a binder. It thickens more predictably, resists moisture swings, and holds texture through multiple heating cycles. Swapping starch for crumbs changes nothing about the flavor, but everything about consistency.

Think about each ingredient in those terms: how it holds up under the conditions of your process, not just how it tastes in a sample jar.

All-Dry or All-Wet Formulations

Mixing dry and wet ingredients often introduces complexity. Water activity, clumping, and uneven mixing show up first when the ratio between the two isn’t stable.

Formulas that lean mostly dry or mostly wet scale more cleanly. A powdered version of a liquid—milk powder instead of liquid milk—can remove variables like temperature and spoilage while keeping the same flavor. The fewer forms you handle, the easier it is to reproduce results.

Cost and Functionality

Two ingredients can achieve the same function while performing very differently on a balance sheet. Bread crumbs and starch both thicken; one costs more per pound and spoils faster.

Each substitution changes your margin, your shelf life, and your storage needs. The ingredient that supports all three wins.

Availability and Seasonality

A recipe that depends on the harvest calendar will behave like the harvest—different every few months. Ingredients vary in moisture, flavor, and price depending on season and region.

Before locking in a supplier, check for year-round sources and backup options. A steady ingredient supply means fewer surprises in production schedules and budgets. Relationships with suppliers who understand small manufacturing volumes often matter more than unit price.

Keep Testing and Recording

Every production run teaches you something about your ingredients: how fast they hydrate, how long they hold texture, how they respond to temperature. Record those patterns —supplier name, lot number, and observations from each batch.

Patterns in those notes will tell you when an ingredient is reliable and when it needs to change. Over time, the right combination of stability, form, cost, and availability becomes clear through results, not guesswork.

For guidance on interpreting those results, see Troubleshooting Common Scale-Up Issues.

Build with Union Kitchen

At Union Kitchen, founders learn by doing—testing ingredients, documenting results, and refining recipes until every batch performs the same way. Through the Union Kitchen Accelerator, we work together to turn those observations into scalable systems and lasting food businesses.